The Latest Hubabaloo

Authentically yours

One’s real life is so often the life that one does not lead

Dictionary definitions describe authenticity in terms of truth; to be authentic is to be closer to the truth. As a philosophical concept espoused by the existentialists, to be authentic is to live unencumbered by external pressures to conform to a society’s norms. In leadership studies, authenticity is a tool that authentic leaders leverage to increase their influence and power: self-reflection mingled with empathy, delivered via charismatic communication and designed to bridge the gap between the manager and the managed. And this LGBT+ history month, I’ve been thinking about personal authenticity, which perhaps most closely aligns with the philosophical ideal, what it means to us as medical students and healthcare professionals. The thought struck me this week as I attempted to auscultate the chest of a ‘simulated patient’ (a onesie stuffed with a pillow) in my first attempt at performing a full respiratory examination, as we will one day be expected to do in OSCEs. 

The process of learning these professional skills does feel very much like acting (listen to this episode of the BMJ’s Sharp Scratch podcast, where the advice really is to ‘act the part’), and acting suggests a level of artifice – of adopting a persona, a metaphorical mask over our real faces. This is all par for the course of becoming a competent medical professional, but it feels at odds with the concept of authenticity as described, and leads to the question of whether authenticity is possible as a medical student or junior doctor. Does the ability to express oneself authentically at work increase with experience and the higher up the professional ladder one climbs? Or, is the permission to present oneself authenticity at work a privilege afforded to some and not others, following all the usual patterns of privilege that exclude minority groups? Is authenticity even a useful or necessary attribute for healthcare professionals at work; does it improve outcomes for patients?

Akin to empathy, authenticity, and by extension, authentic leadership, are terms and concepts that we use in healthcare as a shorthand for something else, something more diffuse like ‘being a good professional’. But, professionalism is, on its face at least, at odds with the concept of authenticity – to do a good job as a professional, you have to speak and act within the bounds of certain constraints that exist to ensure patients get the best care possible, while authenticity would dictate that a person completely free themselves from constraints. I think we would agree that the latter would make for a very dangerous healthcare environment (and probably some quite unpleasant colleagues). But at the same time, I think our working understanding of ‘authenticity’ does encompass a privilege that some do indeed experience at work – the space to express themselves more freely and share more of their identity without fear of sanction. And therefore, through allyship and self-reflection, we should be working for a healthcare environment that breaks down persisting prejudices that make certain expressions of identity difficult, or even dangerous, for some patients and staff. Whether or not this would lead to more ‘authenticity’, I can’t say, but I believe it would have the potential to improve outcomes for those who shoulder more of the burden of identity oppression than others. 

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Stalk Us

Weekly Newsletter

Sign up to our fortnightly newsletter for updates, news and competitions.

Join Study Hub as an

Educator

Open to all students & doctors who are keen on teaching.

Clinical & Communication skills teaching & demonstrations

OSCE prep & examining mocks

Clinical knowledge / case based teaching

SBA Based Revision sessions
Feel free to suggest anything else you would like to teach!

Upcoming Sessions

Newsletter Subscription

It’s the BEST way to stay up to date with everything we’re doing. Expect session timetables, news, deep dives and competitions delivered fortnightly!

Live Session Help

Sorry to hear you’re having issues getting into the session. We don’t want any of our hublings to miss out on the fantastic information that’s being shared.

Please try these steps:
1. Try clearing your browser cache (Ctrl + F5/ CMD + Shift + R) .
2. Try opening the page in an incognito/private window.
3. Audio issues on Apple products: Please ensure ringer volume is on when connecting to computer audio.
4. If none of these work please use the zoom link below to access the session for now and please fill out feedback form on this page explaining what happened after the session so we can improve.

Click Here to Join Via Zoom

Meeting Passcode: 0

Shop Coming Soon!

We’re working hard behind the scenes to create the best range of products for you. Expect everything from scrubs to stationary availible to purchase this Christmas!

Coming Soon!

Our platform wants to centralise resources. Addressing all your needs as a student…

To achieve this we need your help! Please share with us any resources you find useful, and feel other healthcare students should be aware of. Share as many as you possibly can.

Please include a link to the website where the resource can be accessed, and a brief description of why you are recommending we include it in our resource section.
These can be resources for study, or more supportive resources e.g. mindfulmedic.co.uk. But it can also be links to good sites to access cheaper equipment needed as a student e.g. Medisave.co.uk. Or even places that do awesome student discounts… 

In other words share with us all the awesome things you wished were shared with you much earlier than they were!

Days
Hours
Minutes

Coming Soon!

Our platform wants to recognise healthcare professionals are humans too!

To achieve this we want to provide support in all areas, not just your revision – from meal prepping to revision techniques to mindfulness! This October we will be joining forces with some incredible people and organisations to name drop a few:

Mindful Medic

hungry_medics

Themummymedic

Wesleyan

The HCSA

AMBOSS

The founders of BiteMedicine

Tom Watchman founder of Zero to Finals

If you feel you have something to contribute to this section, please get in touch with our collaboration team.

Coming Soon!

Our platform wants to become a supportive community!

To achieve this, we want to work with students and professionals who have developed their own study materials they wish to share with the wider community! On 28th September this section will go live and will give you access to all the materials that have been shared with us. Currently we are compiling resources provided by St Georges University of London’s finest, the BNOCs:
  • Ramzan Bilal
  • Matt Anson
  • Rap the top 100
By 28th September we hope to have materials provided from more contributors from universities across the UK. If you feel you have something to contribute to this section get in touch with our collaboration team.

When sharing your materials with us, we want to make it clear that you retain all intellectual property rights and receive full recognition the work is yours!

Days
Hours
Minutes